Sunday, October 25, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #6
I have concerns about implementing these strategies into my classroom, however. First of all, I'm not sure I would be comfortable with these strategies until I was more familiar with the students I work with. While it is important to know your students personally in order to successfully facilitate these types of circles, it's also important to know the student group, generally. For example, I would want more experience with the types of questions and prompts that would work best with the age group I work with, and what books are most appropriate, and the best way to construct groups.
Further, I think to implement these strategies you need to be very confident in your abilities to control a classroom. Daniels reminds us that these literature circles require that there is "a decentralized classroom, lots of different books being read, and lots of logs and materials circulating, the frequent reshuffling of groups, plenty of noise and movement" and I think all of these things together would be very overwhelming to a newer teacher and things could get out of control quickly if the teacher didn't have lots of confidence and control. I don't imagine that right off the bat I will be confident allowing students to run their own dialogue. I would want a good amount of practice getting students comfortable with the skills needed, in a more controlled environment, before I would lead a circle like this.
Finally, I really think that these strategies probably work with very specific groups of students. Last week's reading by Delpit reminds us that students with different backgrounds approach education and the activities and strategies that teachers use very differently. For example, Daniels suggests that play and fun is an important aspect of the literature circles and I don't doubt that this is true. However, I think with certain groups of students, this kind of instruction and activity could be interpreted differently. For many students, the classroom is not "another kind of dining-room table," it is their ONLY dining-room table and these students likely come to the classroom with a very different relationship towards reading than other students, who have "playful interaction" with reading and writing at home would.
As I consider incorporating these strategies into my own classroom, Daniels' comments on fitting literature circles into a "balanced reading program" resonates with me. Especially when one considers the students who may not get scaffolding in reading and writing at home, it is important not to rely on these strategies too heavily. The authors of these articles do refer to scaffolding and modeling activities to help set students up for this kind of classroom experience, and that is obviously very important. However, it is possible that many students need more direct reading instruction and assistance.
Overall, I think these strategies introduce an interesting aspect of what a language arts classroom can provide and what it can look like.
Sunday, October 18, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #5
I've always prided myself on my "innate" sense of grammar and language use. Writing came naturally to me and I get a sick sort of pleasure correcting reality television stars when they say "he and I" when it should be "him and me." And, for a while now, I've felt that this innate grammatical genius of mine was a significant reason that I would make a fantastic English teacher. Then, I took a linguistics class this summer and I was told, in no uncertain terms, that my "prescriptive" knowledge of grammar was irrelevant and useless in the context of truly understanding and appreciating the complexity of the English language. I have since spent a great deal of time reflecting on this idea that prescriptive, perfect grammar is not a comprehensive measure of one's mastery of language or understanding of the world around us. I am reminded of the ELL students I worked with last year, and the enjoyment I got out of listening to how they manipulated language in order to satisfy their needs and get their points across. These students were so bold, such risk-takers, so unafraid of mistakes and so eager and open to learning. I was in awe of how immodestly they made mistakes, or altered and twisted the English language in creative and interesting ways when they didn't know the word for something. Watching them do this forced me to consider our language from different perspectives and really rethink what it means to "understand" someone else.
In my encounters with various ways of approaching grammar, I've only superficially touched on the idea that "grammar was an indication of class and cultural background in the United States and that there is a bias against people who do not use language "correctly" (Christensen 100). An individual's voice is made up of that person's story. By saying that only one way of speaking, writing, pronouncing - expressing - is "right" marginalizes the stories of a majority of the people that make up this country. Indeed, "when more attention is paid to the way something is written or said than to what is said, students' words and thoughts become devalued" (101).
Is the meaning of the sentence completely lost when a student uses a double negative? When we are confronted with the use of a double negative, do we honestly stop and wonder "wait, WAS there or WASN'T there?!? I'm so confused!" When someone says they "ain't interested" am I suddenly plunged into the dark unknown, the meaning of the conversation I was having gone and lost to me forever? Of course not. But we say that "ain't" is wrong and double negatives is wrong. 2+2=5 is wrong. There is no truth in that equation. But there is truth and meaning in language, regardless of the order in which it comes or the pitch and pace of it. Christensen reminds us that "students must be taught to hold their own voices sacred, to ignore the teachers who have made them feel that what they've said is wrong or bad or stupid" (101).
I agree with Christensen that "often the most creative students [...] are the students that have not succeeded in school [...] while most of the 'advanced' students [...] too often [...] write 'safe' papers" (172-173). Recognizing this is an important way for us, as educators, to value and encourage the "different sets of intellectual capacities" with which our students come to us (172). To use correct grammar and pronunciation as the basis for determining education level, proficiency, creative ability, or thoughtfulness is terribly narrow-minded. Christensen reminds us that "our students' lives and language are unique and important" and that as teachers we have the opportunity to affirm that in our classrooms (102). I love the sentiment that as educators we are privileged to have access to the hearts and minds of these fascinating individuals. These students are growing up in a different world than we did and young people perceive their world without the ball and chain of years and years of previous experience to influence how they interpret their worlds. We are fortunate to have access to this fountain of originality and individuality. It would certainly be missing a huge portion of the joy and excitement that comes from teaching to stifle the voices of this creative minds.
When one considers shrugging off the notions of "'standard and 'nonstandard,'" one is also considering the ethics of teaching. Indeed, as the terms imply, standard is the "rule" and not going by the standards implies breaking rules. Just as teaching standards brings up questions regarding "who made the rules" (Christensen 103)? If we "[a]s teacher [...] must be fair in our dealings with students and conduct classrooms where, literally, justice prevails," then mustn't we allow all voices be heard, no constraints (Christenbury 32)?
Sunday, September 27, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #3
Sunday, September 20, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #2
Additionally, I really responded to the idea, in the article by Clark and Blackburn, of making lifestyles that don't conform to a white, middle-class image more normative (Clark & Blackburn). Even though this article is talking specifically about teaching LGBTQ literature, the concepts they discuss can be applied to any lifestyle that is "alternative" to the homogeneous standard. I recall English classes in high school that had short units devoted to minority writers and alternative lifestyles. This literature was singled out and taught as an anomaly to other types of literature, rather than as another way of looking at a universal theme. At the time, I think this approach was considered fairly progressive, however, the idea of teaching this literature throughout an academic year, integrated into larger themes, makes the subjects more normal, accessible, and universal.
Sunday, September 13, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #1
Scribner's look at how to define literacy adds to the struggle of defining the importance of teaching literature. If I were to choose one of her metaphors that best applied to me, it would be "Literacy as a State of Grace" (Scribner 13). The idea that literacy is important as "a way of developing minds" resonates with me (14). I've always felt that being able to read and interpret literature is a way of engaging many different cognitive skills that can apply to a variety of real life situations that don't immediately have to do with reading. After reading this article, though, I see the limitations of this interpretation of literacy. I recognize that the concept of "necessary life skills" is different to different cultures and communities.
Recognizing the problems with trying to define something so complex and multi-layered emphasizes the need for flexibility and open-mindedness in teaching. In the case narrative about Molly, it is clear that length of time teaching or the number of lessons taught does not influence how to approach each and every class. She explains that what and how she teaches "depends entirely on who my students are" (Beach 42). The idea that each room full of students will influence what your literature philosophy will be is reassuring. When you consider the vast amount of work that we put into each unit, it is reassuring to realize that there is no one right answer about how to approach literature, or that the answer we come up with today doesn't have to be the answer we come up with tomorrow. Trying to determine the importance of teaching literature to every student we will ever have is pretty useless. Every student we come across will have specific needs and our reasons for teaching literature to one student will differ from the reasons we teach literature to another. As I begin to develop my own philosophies about teaching, I will be sure to keep in mind that I can have a different answer for different scenarios.