Sunday, September 27, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #3
Rosenblatt argues that reading is a two-way process between reader and text (Rosenblatt 268). To some extent, this is true. However, if we are to embrace an approach to teaching literature that includes “multiple ways of seeing,” we have to acknowledge that there are far more than two forces at work in the process of reading (Appleman 9). This argument is an important aspect of Cynthia Lewis’ critique of Rosenblatt’s work. Lewis suggests that it is problematic to limit reader response to the personal “at the expense of the social and political” in the instruction of literature (Lewis 254). I firmly agree with Lewis here. For me, an enriching classroom is one in which student response includes far more than the personal, goes beyond the search for the familiar, and seeks to challenge status quo by confronting the various forces that shape our world. Confining responses to literature to the individual experience overlooks a central objective for teaching literature: to “teach the concept of ideology,” which “is generally a social and political construct” (Appleman 2). When interacting with a text becomes an exercise in dismantling the concept of individual differentness and searching, instead, for universal similarities, the historical, political, and social forces that shape and distinguish us are neglected. Recognizing the familiar in a text does not challenge students to question the standard ideologies and “give-ins” of their worlds. As with any discipline, if a student isn’t being challenged, then learning is not occurring. Being uncomfortable and experiencing tension between what we’ve always known and what we’re coming to know is an essential process in the evolution of knowing. When literature “disrupt[s] the reader’s inclination to identify, the text heightens the reader’s self consciousness and text consciousness in a way that should not be viewed as less aesthetic than a more direct or immediate relationship between reader and text” (Lewis 263). Appreciating a text for the insights it can provide that are not immediately relevant to the individual is one way in which to read “both the world and the word” (Appleman 2). Reading, then, is a process of noting and investigating differences and things not previously known about in the text and the forces that shape those differences. It is not the job of the teacher of literature to make sure that students feel comfortable when they read. Meaningful reading happens when traditional ways of thinking are disrupted and the student is presented with a memorable literary experience that is supported by constructive reflection.
Sunday, September 20, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #2
This week's topic - diversity - is verging on the redundant and oversimplified, despite being an incredibly important one. However, I was pleased by the readings in that they were English classroom specific, and that they considered diversity from a multitude of angles. I was especially struck by Ladson-Billings' assertion that "one of the reasons [minority] children experience difficulty in schools is that educators traditionally have attempted to insert culture into the education, instead of inserting education into the culture" (Ladson-Billings 159). That educators should tailor what they teach to the students they are teaching appears to be a recurring theme in curriculum building. One project I assisted with this year was a cultural research project. The students were asked to make a poster and prepare a talk to be given to staff and students at a designated time about their culture. They were asked to do research and link their findings to the topics they had discussed in class. In addition, each student also had to give a report about another student's presentation. Many skills and strategies were utilized during the preparation of this project. However, it was the student's cultures and backgrounds that were the focus on the outcome. It was a successful project and I saw students get very excited to share information about their cultures with others.
Additionally, I really responded to the idea, in the article by Clark and Blackburn, of making lifestyles that don't conform to a white, middle-class image more normative (Clark & Blackburn). Even though this article is talking specifically about teaching LGBTQ literature, the concepts they discuss can be applied to any lifestyle that is "alternative" to the homogeneous standard. I recall English classes in high school that had short units devoted to minority writers and alternative lifestyles. This literature was singled out and taught as an anomaly to other types of literature, rather than as another way of looking at a universal theme. At the time, I think this approach was considered fairly progressive, however, the idea of teaching this literature throughout an academic year, integrated into larger themes, makes the subjects more normal, accessible, and universal.
Additionally, I really responded to the idea, in the article by Clark and Blackburn, of making lifestyles that don't conform to a white, middle-class image more normative (Clark & Blackburn). Even though this article is talking specifically about teaching LGBTQ literature, the concepts they discuss can be applied to any lifestyle that is "alternative" to the homogeneous standard. I recall English classes in high school that had short units devoted to minority writers and alternative lifestyles. This literature was singled out and taught as an anomaly to other types of literature, rather than as another way of looking at a universal theme. At the time, I think this approach was considered fairly progressive, however, the idea of teaching this literature throughout an academic year, integrated into larger themes, makes the subjects more normal, accessible, and universal.
Sunday, September 13, 2009
CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #1
The readings this week encouraged me to think about defining what it means to me to teach literature. It occurs to me that I took for granted the answer to the question, "why do I want to teach literature?" Without being asked to define my purpose directly, the answer seems obvious. I love literature and recognize the importance it plays in living a full and satisfying life, etc. However, when pressed to expand on this idea and offer a more concrete analysis for why I do what I do, I find my reasons are only partially realized - is "full and satisfying" the same for everyone? In trying to achive that goal for everyone, will it help to teach the same thing to every group of students over my 20-30 year career?
Scribner's look at how to define literacy adds to the struggle of defining the importance of teaching literature. If I were to choose one of her metaphors that best applied to me, it would be "Literacy as a State of Grace" (Scribner 13). The idea that literacy is important as "a way of developing minds" resonates with me (14). I've always felt that being able to read and interpret literature is a way of engaging many different cognitive skills that can apply to a variety of real life situations that don't immediately have to do with reading. After reading this article, though, I see the limitations of this interpretation of literacy. I recognize that the concept of "necessary life skills" is different to different cultures and communities.
Recognizing the problems with trying to define something so complex and multi-layered emphasizes the need for flexibility and open-mindedness in teaching. In the case narrative about Molly, it is clear that length of time teaching or the number of lessons taught does not influence how to approach each and every class. She explains that what and how she teaches "depends entirely on who my students are" (Beach 42). The idea that each room full of students will influence what your literature philosophy will be is reassuring. When you consider the vast amount of work that we put into each unit, it is reassuring to realize that there is no one right answer about how to approach literature, or that the answer we come up with today doesn't have to be the answer we come up with tomorrow. Trying to determine the importance of teaching literature to every student we will ever have is pretty useless. Every student we come across will have specific needs and our reasons for teaching literature to one student will differ from the reasons we teach literature to another. As I begin to develop my own philosophies about teaching, I will be sure to keep in mind that I can have a different answer for different scenarios.
Scribner's look at how to define literacy adds to the struggle of defining the importance of teaching literature. If I were to choose one of her metaphors that best applied to me, it would be "Literacy as a State of Grace" (Scribner 13). The idea that literacy is important as "a way of developing minds" resonates with me (14). I've always felt that being able to read and interpret literature is a way of engaging many different cognitive skills that can apply to a variety of real life situations that don't immediately have to do with reading. After reading this article, though, I see the limitations of this interpretation of literacy. I recognize that the concept of "necessary life skills" is different to different cultures and communities.
Recognizing the problems with trying to define something so complex and multi-layered emphasizes the need for flexibility and open-mindedness in teaching. In the case narrative about Molly, it is clear that length of time teaching or the number of lessons taught does not influence how to approach each and every class. She explains that what and how she teaches "depends entirely on who my students are" (Beach 42). The idea that each room full of students will influence what your literature philosophy will be is reassuring. When you consider the vast amount of work that we put into each unit, it is reassuring to realize that there is no one right answer about how to approach literature, or that the answer we come up with today doesn't have to be the answer we come up with tomorrow. Trying to determine the importance of teaching literature to every student we will ever have is pretty useless. Every student we come across will have specific needs and our reasons for teaching literature to one student will differ from the reasons we teach literature to another. As I begin to develop my own philosophies about teaching, I will be sure to keep in mind that I can have a different answer for different scenarios.
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)