When I read the following line, my heart leapt a little: “We believe that this form of writing [timed writing assessments] should be treated as a genre that students need practice mastering” (Newkirk and Kent 66). I truly feel, after reading that line, that a majority of my anxiety over teaching writing and assessing writing has been resolved. I understand the author’s caution to be sure that the majority of time writing is not spent just on test preparation, and that it is important to stress voice and a measure of creativity, but I really relate to the idea that timed high-stakes test writing be treated separately from other forms of writing. I think that this sends the message that there is a time and a place for the considerations that go into those pieces of writing, but when we’re considering other styles, most of those conventions can be, if not ignored, at least put on the back burner. Once it is recognized that this type of writing is important, but also very specific, it gives us, as educators, the freedom to arrange it so that it does not dominate instruction of other forms of writing.
I am finding I am very drawn to the idea, also, of portfolios and grading “not just the final product […] but also the student’s writing process, growth as a writer, and commitment to his own writing development” (Dornan 188). By teaching writing to young people, we are acknowledging that they do not know how to do this themselves. They are being taught. They should be graded on the learning, not the perfecting. I have never used a portfolio in my own schooling and as I reflect on the readings about portfolios, including the other article by Richard Kent, and how I intend on using them in my classroom, I genuinely think I would have turned out to be a better writer if I had ever had experience with a writing portfolio. I have always approached school writing as something that was supposed to come out perfect the first time. The product was what mattered and so I never learned to value the process or the practice. I do not want my students to leave my class with this same mentality. I think it stifles creativity and makes students feel inadequate when they struggle with early drafts. If they think that all writing is supposed to come out neat and tidy the first time, they feel like a failure when they need to revise and revise and revise. What a shame.
http://webeasysearch.com/search/search.cgi?q=writing+contests
This is a website that directs educators to various writing contests around the country. I think that writing contests would be an interesting form of motivation for students.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Wednesday, February 3, 2010
Post 2 for 2-4-10
It's overwhelming to read so much about the teaching of writing in one sitting. There is a lot of work involved in teaching writing to high schoolers - a lot of planning, front-loading, feedback giving, and grading. However, I am particularly struck in this week's readings by some of the recurring themes: writing is hard, necessary, and the process can be varied greatly. Additionally, despite being a little overwhelmed, I am really inspired by the reading this week and anxious to get to the writing component of my job. Last week I expressed a little anxiety over teaching writing because it is not something I had previously thought much about. After attending the writing workshop today and seeing the kids there expressing themselves and expanding their awareness and really becoming more of who they are right in front of our eyes really reminded me of the power of self-expression and how essential it is to a young person's development. I am really excited to ignite insight and thoughtfulness in this way to my students, as well as explore some writing processes myself along the way!
The appendices in the Dornan book provides nice outlines for teaching some writing styles and offers the aspiring teacher a number of tips for setting up a classroom that successfully provides students with a safe, nurturing, and productive environment in which to write and think. Kent also provides many ideas for how to set up a writing schedule and a way of connecting with students through writing. I think it's always important to be supportive and encouraging to our students, regardless of the discipline, but it seems even more important in a classroom that asks students to be so candid, open, and vulnerable. In order for students to be honest and risky in their expressions it is essential for the English teacher to develop really trusting and secure relationships with their students. Even though I think it is unrealistic to put all of the suggestions and tips into practice in my own classroom, I think these readings did offer good insight into the importance of organizing the writing curriculum and establishing a comfortable, honest, and natural dialogue with the students. I believe that establishing the former makes securing the latter much easier. I agree with the authors of Within and Beyond the Writing Process when the assert that "when we write within a supportive, nurturing environment that encourages risk taking and experimentation with form, language, and ideas, we can accept error and momentary ineptitude as an inevitable part of our writing development" (Dornan 5).
The reading about audience was a bit of a struggle for me. It's difficult to digest a paper about one aspect of writing in such a formal way. I relate much more easily to the real life accounts in the textbooks and the notion that "there is no singular writing process - there are multiple processes - and the processes are recursive rather than linear" (6). While I recognize that the authors of the article were trying to dispel the idea that there is one right way to consider the audience as one writes, I still think it was reductive and oversimplified, couched in fancy language and shallow research. I prefer to think about the process and how people go about it to be an ongoing debate, the general consensus of which changes from genre to genre and topic to topic and personal preference to personal preference. I think it's dangerous to make formal prescriptions about the act of writing. If we teach students that there is a right or wrong way to consider the audience in our writing, we risk cutting off brilliant ideas due to unnecessary "fears." I do, though, expect the conversation to come up in my classroom. If there is a debate about something in the writing or literary world, I would definitely want to bring the conversation into my class and have the students participate in it.
http://mwp.umn.edu/
I chose this link because I attended the Young Writer's Conference today and was blown away by the level of involvement, reflection, and insight the students had to offer. I think the Minnesota Writing Project is really interesting and has many tools for an English teacher.
The appendices in the Dornan book provides nice outlines for teaching some writing styles and offers the aspiring teacher a number of tips for setting up a classroom that successfully provides students with a safe, nurturing, and productive environment in which to write and think. Kent also provides many ideas for how to set up a writing schedule and a way of connecting with students through writing. I think it's always important to be supportive and encouraging to our students, regardless of the discipline, but it seems even more important in a classroom that asks students to be so candid, open, and vulnerable. In order for students to be honest and risky in their expressions it is essential for the English teacher to develop really trusting and secure relationships with their students. Even though I think it is unrealistic to put all of the suggestions and tips into practice in my own classroom, I think these readings did offer good insight into the importance of organizing the writing curriculum and establishing a comfortable, honest, and natural dialogue with the students. I believe that establishing the former makes securing the latter much easier. I agree with the authors of Within and Beyond the Writing Process when the assert that "when we write within a supportive, nurturing environment that encourages risk taking and experimentation with form, language, and ideas, we can accept error and momentary ineptitude as an inevitable part of our writing development" (Dornan 5).
The reading about audience was a bit of a struggle for me. It's difficult to digest a paper about one aspect of writing in such a formal way. I relate much more easily to the real life accounts in the textbooks and the notion that "there is no singular writing process - there are multiple processes - and the processes are recursive rather than linear" (6). While I recognize that the authors of the article were trying to dispel the idea that there is one right way to consider the audience as one writes, I still think it was reductive and oversimplified, couched in fancy language and shallow research. I prefer to think about the process and how people go about it to be an ongoing debate, the general consensus of which changes from genre to genre and topic to topic and personal preference to personal preference. I think it's dangerous to make formal prescriptions about the act of writing. If we teach students that there is a right or wrong way to consider the audience in our writing, we risk cutting off brilliant ideas due to unnecessary "fears." I do, though, expect the conversation to come up in my classroom. If there is a debate about something in the writing or literary world, I would definitely want to bring the conversation into my class and have the students participate in it.
http://mwp.umn.edu/
I chose this link because I attended the Young Writer's Conference today and was blown away by the level of involvement, reflection, and insight the students had to offer. I think the Minnesota Writing Project is really interesting and has many tools for an English teacher.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)