Response – The Arrival
Adolescent Literature - Brendler
7 December 2010
Personal Response
Wow. This book blew me away. I expected that I would like it, but I didn’t think it would affect me the same way a book with words affects me. But it did. In some ways, it was even more emotional as a graphic novel without words than it would have been with them.
There were a few panels that really moved me. The first one that I really noticed was towards the beginning, when the man is getting on the train and there is a close-up of his hands holding his wife’s and child’s hand and then they let go. It’s such a small, simple detail that conveys the situation really well. The reader (viewer?) senses what is happening and experiences the separation. Up to this point in the story, I actually thought the whole family was leaving. This was the panel where I learned he was leaving his family behind.
The next panel I enjoyed had all the pictures of the clouds, indicating the amount of time he had been on the boat. I found this an interesting way to communicate this, as one can imagine that all that time on a boat, one of the only ways to mark how time is passing is to just watch the weather. The author does the same thing towards the end of the story, where we see a small plant going through the growth stages of a year. Again, for a lonely man in an unfamiliar world, watching the seasons pass would be the only way to see time passing without his family.
Even without dialogue or narrative, I became very emotionally invested in this character. The way his emotions were conveyed – his loneliness, confusion, and desperation – almost entirely through illustrations of his face, and I was really drawn in.
Critical Response
This is an emotional book, with a lot of purpose. It very successfully conveys the loneliness and confusion of moving to a new place without knowing the language or the people. Many people could relate to this story and the way that it is told – through pictures only – is a big reason for this. The author obviously has a lot of sympathy and compassion for his character, but the story wouldn’t have been quite as moving without the illustrations. This is a familiar story told in an unfamiliar way and that is its strength.
Various details of what it is like to be away from home and loved ones are conveyed through the pictures that would have been very difficult with words. When the man first opens his suitcase, his first impression is that it is all that he has left of home and he sees his wife and daughter at the table without him, before turning back into his clothes and the picture he brought of them.
Another successful aspect of this story is that the author keeps the reasons for why the man and other refugees left their countries somewhat ambiguous. Some of the illustrations suggest familiar evils that have resulted in the displacement of many people, but as readers, we are left with our own interpretations. This same ambiguity applies to the city where the man finds himself. Of course, there are many aspects of this city that imply New York City, but the way the author doesn’t make anything explicit allows the reader to experience the same level of discomfort and alienation that the man does.
Overall, this was a very successful book about feeling like an outsider, finding one’s way, trusting in others, and maintaining hope in a hostile situation. The man’s little pet, for me, represents the ability in each of us to adjust to any situation and comfort ourselves when things are difficult.
No comments:
Post a Comment