Response – The People Could Fly
Adolescent Literature - Brendler
5 October 2010
Personal Response
There were two things I especially liked in this book. The first was the pictures. When I was flipping through the book, before I started it, I thought the pictures looked a little amateurish, but I found that they added a lot to the stories once I began reading them. The other thing I really liked was the natural, colloquial tone of them. I could really hear the voice in my head and I felt like I was sitting on a porch stoop in the South listening to an old grandma tell all the stories of her childhood. The stories told in the Gullah dialect appealed to me the most. My favorite stories were, “Bruh Alligator Meets Trouble,” “The Beautiful Girl of the Moon Tower,” “The Two Johns,” “John and the Devil’s Daughter,” “A Peculiar Such Thing,” “Better Wait Till Martin Comes,” and “The People Could Fly.”
The book I purchased was used from an Amazon.com dealer and it was once in a school library. It is wrapped in protective plastic and has a California school library stamp on the inside. It also has a pocket on the inside cover with the borrow card still in it. You can tell it’s a well-used book and this information is confirmed by the number of people who checked it out between the years of 1989 and 1999. On the outside and again on the inside cover there is a DISCARD sticker. I don’t know why all this information added so much to my reading experience, but it did. I think it has something to do with the idea of having resurrected a book from destruction or oblivion. It is a reminder that these are important stories that should not be forgotten. They are the voice of our history and culture. The book’s history seemed to help connect me to the history within it.
Critical Response
This book has such a unique style to it that successfully draws the reader in. The easy way that each story is introduced, such as, “Heard tell about Doctor Rabbit and Brother Fox,” or “Let’s talk about one time,” makes the reader feel at ease because the story seems more accessible. The colloquial tone of the stories helps that too. In the story “Bruh Alligator and Bruh Deer,” the narrator asks the reader, “How Bruh Deer gone get across go see his family?” This sense that the reader is being spoken to and that they are intimate with the narrator makes the stories themselves more intimate. The reader can hear the voice telling the story. The stories are told just the way they’d be told to a child or room full of people after a meal. In the story “The Peculiar Such Thing,” the narrator inserts an opinion and exclamation, just as one would if they were telling a story about something that happened to them at the store that day. “This fellow, like he had no sense, he cooked the great, big, long tail. Yes, he did. It tasted sweet and he ate it. Goodness!” You can just hear the giggles and twitters of young children as this is told to them.
The layout and order of the stories was very conducive to this collection of stories. Beginning with the stories about animals allows the reader a gentle entrance to the stories. Many people reading this might not be familiar with the style or content of stories like these, but most every culture has animal stories. This is something a reader could relate to and help ease them into the style and dialect of the stories to come. After the animal stories come the “fanciful” stories about magic, riddles, and tall tales. Again, this is a wise introduction to topics that may be unfamiliar to some, but are told in a recognizable way. From there, the book moves into supernatural tales. These stories border on scary, but they are digested much more easily because of the stories that have come before them. Finally, the freedom tales. The reader has likely been waiting for these, but I think it works having them at the end. They are gentle reminders of where these stories came from and the conditions that gave rise to them. However, having them at the end allowed the reader to enjoy them for what they were, without having them all appear to be about slavery. Also, knowing how all the other stories were told, with magic and riddles, it was nice to see those fanciful elements be applied to real-life conditions that the people telling them were living in.
At first, I thought the author’s notes at the end of each story were going to be distracting and not very helpful. However, the more I read, the more I would get anxious to read what she had to say, while I was reading. I found that her comments often added really interesting layers to the stories.
I, too, loved the layout of this collection of fables. As I read what you wrote about this, I had a thought. I wonder if the fables were in a chronological-type order. What I mean is, the animal tales are for children, the fanciful tales are for older children, the supernatural tales are for young adults, and the freedom tales are for adults. I think this could put some sense to the order. I also enjoyed the information provided at the end of the fables. I liked getting the story behind the story. My favorites were The Two Johns and Carrying the Running-Aways. I liked them for very different reasons, just like you. The one-upsmanship in The Two Johns was very funny -- especially the part about the grandmother. I liked Carrying the Running-Aways best because we find out at the end of the fable that it the story of Virginia Hamilton's ancestors. Very cool.
ReplyDeleteHi Molly,
ReplyDeleteI responded to your post on Tuesday evening after class, but I don't see it here now. Hopefully you and Beth saw it.
In case it was lost, I commented on the order of the sections in collection. Your writing led me to wonder if the collection was put in order based upon the reader's age. For example, the animal stories were simple and would appeal to young children. The fanciful stories would appeal to older children while the supernatural stories might appeal to teens. And, the freedom stories would appeal to adults. Thus, giving the collection a "chronological" sequence to the book.
I also enjoyed your reflection of where you had purchased your book and its life before you received it. I love thinking about who has read books before me. I, too, wonder what they people are like and if they enjoyed the same things about the book or if they had a different experience with the text. It is amazing to me to think that a book might be in a collection for decades and literally hundreds of patrons would have read it over time.
Thanks for sharing your favorite tales in the collection as well. It was great to see that you had found things you liked in the book, just like I did. My favorite story was The Two Johns. The best part of that story was when the put the deceased grandmother in the store and scared the storekeeper. I laughed out loud.
Thanks again, and I am sorry if you didn't see my original post -- I'm not sure what happened to it.
I usually don’t post in Blogs but your blog forced me to, amazing work.. beautiful …
ReplyDeleteHey, I can't view your site properly within Opera, I actually hope you look into fixing this.
ReplyDeleteWelcome to here I am really glad to be here to share my online shopping experience with you.
ReplyDelete