Response – The Graveyard Book
Adolescent Literature - Brendler
26 October 2010
Personal Response
I really don’t like reading fantasy fiction. I have a hard time getting into it and buying into it. This book was no different. I had a really hard time getting into it and found myself not buying into it a lot in the beginning. And while this is certainly not my favorite book we’ve read so far, it definitely did a lot to change my perception of fantasy fiction. In the end, I really enjoyed this book and feel it has much to offer an adolescent reader. It satisfied all the major requirements of fantasy and, overall, I felt it was captivating and interesting.
Reading this book reminded me a little of reading The Secret Garden. This was one of my favorite books when I was young. One of the things I liked so much about it was the sense of lush, outdoors adventure, which this book had a lot of. I loved the descriptions of Bod wandering through the graveyard after reading Thackeray’s book, or creeping around Potter’s Field. The details of the woods and the land gave me a feeling of being there and being able to sense the isolation and out-of-this-worldliness of the story. I think this setting is a nice compliment to the often barren and isolating world of a typical adolescent. Perhaps it is a nice compliment, also, to the often barren and isolating world of being an adult? One reason I think I often avoid reading fantasy is that certain adolescent longings and feeling do surface from reading it, which makes me feel a little uncomfortable, at first. Once I enter that world, though, I find I enjoy it and lose myself in it, somewhat. But there is something uncomfortable in this comfort: do I long for my own adolescence? Do I have unresolved issues lingering from that time in my life? Or, more probably, do we all harbor longings and unresolved issues from this important, formative period in our lives and are we simply conditioned, as we age, to suppress those things and pretend that they don’t exist in an attempt to convince ourselves and/or others that we’re well-adjusted adults not in need of revisiting our youth? I think these are important questions to consider as adults approaching adolescent literature, particularly fantasy; for as we age, it becomes more difficult to suspend disbelief and enter, in a meaningful way, a world different from our own. In any event, this book was enjoyable to me on an adult level as well as an adolescent one.
Finally, I was pleasantly surprised by how compelling the question of where the borders between the living and the dead reside. I think it’s a difficult task for a writer to tackle the issue of death and force their readers to consider the afterlife and what it means to live a meaningful life. This effort can easily come off as condescending, trite, or preachy. This story, though, delicately managed to allow the reader to consider these questions in their own way.
Critical Response
Reading and responding to the literature we’ve read in this course so far, I have learned to approach the characters more like an adolescent than as an adult and to think about certain characterizations from their point-of-view rather than my own. For example, when I was reading Waiting for Alaska, I was not convinced of the characterization of The Eagle. I thought he was wildly underdeveloped and misrepresented. The comments I received for my critique urged me to consider his role from an adolescent’s perspective rather than from an adult’s. I think I brought that perspective to a reading of the “adults” – alive and dead – in this story. I think that Bod’s caretakers were wonderfully developed for a young audience. They were appropriately seen from the point-of-view of a six-year-old, eight-year-old, ten-year-old, etc. Additionally, Gaiman managed, by virtue of the genre in which he is working, to put distance between actual adults and the adults in his novel. On the one hand, he somewhat tongue-and-cheek implies that adults sometimes seem like they are 900 years older than young people, but he also manages to suggest that an actual adolescent’s authority figures aren’t that out of touch.
Bod’s development was equally well developed. His actions and perceptions were appropriate at each stage of his growth. When he was younger, things seemed far more mysterious, shrouded, and confusing. As he aged, he was able to make more sophisticated assumptions and conclusions about what was going on around him. This culminated in his final showdown with the Jacks and his ability to put all that he had learned together and take care of himself (even if this whole sequence was a little rushed and cliché).
This story introduced history as relevant, obscure, and mysterious, seamlessly. Bringing history and issues regarding how history is recorded and passed on into an engaging adolescent book is not a simple task. A reluctant reader who, for example, might utterly shun historical novels could take this book and be asked to consider how history might be told differently from the people who lived it versus how it is delivered in textbook form and actually think about it!
You can create your own free blog on WordPress.com. Literature
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your reflection on how The Graveyard Book reminded you of your childhood. I thought the same thing as well. We must have some sort of fascination with death and graveyards when we are children. I remember living a block or so from an old graveyard and always wondering about it. Even thought it was kind of creepy, we played in there all the time. Many years later, I was visiting my childhood neighborhood with a friend. It was dark out and he did not know the area at all. But as we were driving away, he remarked that he thought the neighborhood was really creepy. He did not know about graveyard. Weird huh?
ReplyDeleteI liked what you said about the character development of Bod's parents. I also thought that Silas was an amazing character as well. There was depth, mystery, and compassion. He reminded me of Sirius Black in the Harry Potter books. Every child should have another adult to look out for them and Silas did that job very well.
Another thing I really liked about the book was the format. As we talked about in class, each chapter was a short story in and of itself. While I did not especially like this book as much as some of the other books we have read this semester, I did really like this particular feature of the book. I also thought the artwork enhanced the overall imagery of the book.
While I do not think this is a book I would read again, I would recommend it for middle school students.
Man, really want to know how can you be that smart, lol...great read, thanks.
ReplyDelete