Response - Luna
Adolescent Lit - Brendler
19 October 2010
Personal Response
I was quite moved by this book. I thought it was written with a really stark honesty that addressed a lot of the realities of how a teenager would deal with this issue. I was worried going into a reading of this book that the issue would be idealized, glorified, or glossed over. This book did none of those things. I have one trans friend, well, more like an acquaintance. He is a she-to-he trans and even though I have been hugely supportive of his transition, I have really struggled to completely understand it. Since we’re not too good of friends, I felt uncomfortable asking too intimate questions. But I saw his voice deepen dramatically, begin fundraising for breast-reduction surgery, and generally turn into a guy, and I have been really curious about the process. I have tried to do research on the Internet and get mostly scientific information about hormones and surgeries, which are informative to an extent, but what I was really curious about was what this whole process is really about. I understand it in straightforward terms, but what about the day-to-day realities? That was what I’ve been after, and this book provided me with a lot of insight into what I’ve been wondering about. Issues of gender and sexual orientation are becoming much less taboo and so we know that adolescents are aware of these realities and there is no way they don’t have questions about them. If I do, they do. This book provides me with a vocabulary and a perspective, which makes addressing this issue and asking my friend questions much easier. I genuinely think that the sensitivity this book shows this issue can provide kids with these tools, too.
Critical Response
A book dealing with an issue like this takes on the enormous task of having to challenge people to relate to a situation that is likely very foreign to them. For the readers who can relate, it takes on the additional challenge of having to portray a delicate issue that still has a lot of stigma associated with it in a way that is not condescending, over-simplified, or in a way that will perpetuate stereotypes and prejudice. That is a difficult line to walk. The way the story oscillates between current action and flashbacks helps accomplish this job. Readers can easily relate to the current action: the horrors of high school, parents, feeling different. Even if a teen isn’t dealing with this particular issue, chances are they are or have dealt with something that they wanted to hide from others, or made them feel like they stick out. The flashbacks help the reader who is unfamiliar with this situation understand the inherent nature of being transgender. When Regan remembers young Liam asking his mom to “take it [his penis] off,” the reader is instantly struck by the confusion that must go on in the mind of someone who feels they weren’t born right. Regan’s voice is very natural and believable. She is the perfect combination of sassy, smart, witty young woman and self-conscious, awkward teenager. She is a rare teen narrator that is pretty reliable. She is probably at her most authentic when she is screaming and questioning things in her own mind. After Liam is caught dressing up at the Materas’ house, her feelings really start bubbling to the surface. “Everything I remembered about me interleaved with Liam. His life. Her struggle. Where were my memories? Where was my life?” These emotions are so real and I suspect that any younger sibling feels like this sometimes. The real humanity of the story comes out when Regan struggles with her love for her brother and her desire to be independent. Every teenager has to, at some point, reconcile family and self and we see Liam/Luna do this too. He/she does see his dependence on Regan and has to reconcile his fears and desires. One might argue that having the story of Luna told from the point-of-view of her sister is something of a cop out. However, this point-of-view actually enhances the humanity and universality of the story. Having the story told from Luna’s perspective could have alienated the reader from the entirety of the experience of dealing with something so substantial. If had been told by Luna, the reader might not have noticed how this issue relates to them. Having it come from Regan, the reader recognizes that someone close to them, in their family, at school, or next-door might be dealing with something like this. This perspective is important for young readers to recognize. Young trans readers might come away from a reading of this recognizing that there are other people out there like them and that there are ways of dealing with it, places for them to go, and people to talk to.
Helpful blog, bookmarked the website with hopes to read more!
ReplyDeleteIt was so great to read your post about your reaction to Luna. I, too, related it to personal experience. In my case, my brother is bisexual and has not chosen to share this information with anyone else. In fact, the only reason I know is that his ex-wife told me about it several years ago. He still struggles in life and I wonder if he were able to be his authentic self if some of these struggles would go away. I agree that the author shares this message in a sensitive and unique way. I suspect that young people who are going through a similar experience would find common ground and understanding through this story. I wrote in my response about the universal nature of this story as well. While gender identity is perhaps a unique perspective, self identity as a whole is a universal theme for young people and reading high quality literature around the subject can enhance our understanding of ourselves and others.
ReplyDeleteSorry for my bad english. Thank you so much for your good post. Your post helped me in my college assignment, If you can provide me more details please email me.
ReplyDelete