Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Going Bovine

Response – Going Bovine

Adolescent Literature - Brendler

26 October 2010

Personal Response

This book kind of blew my mind. I was really skeptical about it at first, but once I got into it, I could not put it down. I wasn’t totally convinced I liked fantasy fiction after reading The Graveyard Book, but this one has me converted. I was completely engaged in it, totally invested in Cameron, Dulcie, Gonzo, and Balder, and utterly mesmerized by the enormity of the content and landscape. Leaving this book was like leaving The Book Thief. I did not want to leave the characters, who have begun to feel like new friends that I want to get to know better.

I’m not sure how I would have liked this book as a teenager. I didn’t really like books like this when I was younger, but I think that was a personal thing, and I could see teenagers being really engaged with it. I think the audience for this book is important to how it is received. I could see a good many teens and adults being utterly confused by this book. How many kids would make the connection between CESSNAB and the pep rally Cameron’s school throws for him? The ones who would are, first of all, probably a lot like Cameron, and would also really enjoy this book’s satirical attitude. But, then again, I think people who don’t make connections like that in this book could still enjoy it. The book’s clever critique of the American landscape is subtle and poignant and I think that even when the significance of some aspects of the story aren’t immediately clear to the reader, they are still meaningful.

I was reminded of Tom Robbins while reading this book. I remember when I first picked up Still Life with Woodpecker thinking how in the world he was going to pull off a story set in a pack of Camel cigarettes, and being so stunned with surprise and awe when it came off so well. I felt the same way about this book. After reading the jacket summary, I was really curious and skeptical about how Bray was going to pull off a good, believable story about a kid with mad cow disease, a punk-rock angel, a yard-gnome, cults, etc., but around every corner of this story, I was stunned at the ease with which she maneuvered me into believing everything that was happening, doubting that it was a hallucination, and convinced that Cameron and Co. would find a cure and all would be well.

Critical Response

Sometimes when adult authors adopt the voice of a contemporary young person and tries to make it sound hip, current, and catchy, it comes off sounding forced and cheesy. However, the language in this book – dialogue, internal monologue, etc. – seemed very realistic. The characters were infused with a clumsy teenaged confidence that wavered at times and puffed out occasionally. The cadences were nicely conveyed with the use of ellipses, italics, commas, and pauses, which makes the language much more authentic. Bray did not shy away from using curse words and slang, which, again added authenticity and infuses the book with a quiet nod of respect towards young people and their worlds. She does this further by allowing her characters to act like real teenagers. They swear, drink, smoke pot, have sex, disobey authority figures, etc. but they are still good kids. By offering a realistic portrait of teenage life, Bray legitimizes adolescence and acknowledges the power of youth to invent language, rediscover reality, and question everything.

The adults in this book were portrayed refreshingly evenly. At first, we see Cameron’s parents the way most teenagers see their parents – flawed, out-of-touch, obstacles.  But as he gets sicker and flashbacks to when he was younger and catches snippets of what they are going through watching him die, he starts to see them as real people who are trying their best and dealing with life as it comes to them, too. Bray is able to portray Cameron’s family sympathetically mostly because, under the drama, flair, and craziness that is the bulk of the story, this is actually a very sad story. Cameron is dying; he is in pain and fading away and his family is watching this. Character’s humanity comes through when they go through something painful and raw. Writing a sad, painful, raw story for teenagers that also has a lesson to it is not an easy task, but this is a successful adolescent coming-of-age story that manages to teach some things, is funny and sad all at once.

The most successful aspect of this story, for me, was it’s ability to keep the reader compulsively turn the page to literally find out what happens. It confidently straddles the line between totally unbelievable and utterly believable. The reader knows this has to be a hallucination, but still turns the page to make sure and figure out how Cameron’s going to get well and not die. When he does, it’s really sad.

1 comment:

  1. I loved Going Bovine too. In fact, much more so than The Graveyard Book. I agree with you in that the best part of this story is the relationships that development between Cameron, Dulcie, Gonzo, and Baler. Their journey was hilarious. We talked in class how the author seemed to toss in every random thought she had while she was writing the story. I guess that ties into the randomness of the story. Or, as Cameron discovers, is that the random may not be so random after all. As Cameron is taking his final journal, these characters help him each step of the way. I kept wishing that Cameron wouldn't die. Even up until the end, I kept hoping that he would get better. The hardest part for me was the fact that he didn't get better. The rest of the story was fun, exciting, terrifying, etc. In the end, Cameron's death is so very sad.

    ReplyDelete