Sunday, September 27, 2009

CI 5441 - Course Readings Post #3

Rosenblatt argues that reading is a two-way process between reader and text (Rosenblatt 268).  To some extent, this is true.  However, if we are to embrace an approach to teaching literature that includes “multiple ways of seeing,” we have to acknowledge that there are far more than two forces at work in the process of reading (Appleman 9).  This argument is an important aspect of Cynthia Lewis’ critique of Rosenblatt’s work.  Lewis suggests that it is problematic to limit reader response to the personal “at the expense of the social and political” in the instruction of literature (Lewis 254).  I firmly agree with Lewis here.  For me, an enriching classroom is one in which student response includes far more than the personal, goes beyond the search for the familiar, and seeks to challenge status quo by confronting the various forces that shape our world.   Confining responses to literature to the individual experience overlooks a central objective for teaching literature: to “teach the concept of ideology,” which “is generally a social and political construct” (Appleman 2).  When interacting with a text becomes an exercise in dismantling the concept of individual differentness and searching, instead, for universal similarities, the historical, political, and social forces that shape and distinguish us are neglected.  Recognizing the familiar in a text does not challenge students to question the standard ideologies and “give-ins” of their worlds.  As with any discipline, if a student isn’t being challenged, then learning is not occurring.  Being uncomfortable and experiencing tension between what we’ve always known and what we’re coming to know is an essential process in the evolution of knowing.  When literature “disrupt[s] the reader’s inclination to identify, the text heightens the reader’s self consciousness and text consciousness in a way that should not be viewed as less aesthetic than a more direct or immediate relationship between reader and text” (Lewis 263).  Appreciating a text for the insights it can provide that are not immediately relevant to the individual is one way in which to read “both the world and the word” (Appleman 2).  Reading, then, is a process of noting and investigating differences and things not previously known about in the text and the forces that shape those differences.  It is not the job of the teacher of literature to make sure that students feel comfortable when they read.  Meaningful reading happens when traditional ways of thinking are disrupted and the student is presented with a memorable literary experience that is supported by constructive reflection.

1 comment:

  1. Interesting post. I think that a lot of the difficult parts of teaching literature involve finding the happy medium between texts that challenge students, and texts that students feel that they understand. That may sound like a vague thing to say, but I think it is a middle way kind of thing. I agree that student's should be challenged by the texts they read. It'll be interesting to see what kinds of response inspire student's to delve deeper into literary criticism on their own.

    ReplyDelete